Yankees Reality Check Leaves Evan Under Fire

Aaron Judge’s injury has completely changed the Yankees conversation. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash challenge Evan Roberts over his season-long belief that the Yankees were the American League’s best team, arguing that Tampa Bay has proven otherwise and that New York’s flaws can no longer be ignored.

Evan owns being wrong about Judge’s injury but refuses to bury the Yankees’ postseason chances, insisting a short series can still swing their way. The debate turns to the overworked bullpen, Anthony Volpe, Spencer Jones and whether this roster was ever as dominant as expected. Plus, Jets fans vent after the loss to Green Bay, with the offense’s late-game collapse, missed fumble recoveries and frustrating mistakes coming under fire.