Hour 3: Yankees’ Playoff Defense Has Become a Nightmare

The Yankees’ defense melted down again in Tampa, leaving Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wondering why the same fatal flaws keep resurfacing under Aaron Boone. Cam Schlittler delivered a fascinating postgame message, first saying the Yankees “didn’t show up” before taking the blame himself, while Tiki’s criticism of Boone’s lack of accountability from 2024 suddenly sounds just as relevant today.
The hour also ranks the Yankees’ brutal defensive miscues, revisits their painful history of postseason near-miss home runs and debates whether this team can actually recover. Plus, John Harbaugh admits he regretted an aggressive two-point decision, Tiki celebrates his victory on The Weakest Link, and Shaun Morash delivers a bleak prediction for when the Yankees might win again.