Loading episode…
Loading episode…

Soccer
Listen guide
"WHY DIDN'T ISAK APPEAL? Lynch's Verdict on Liverpool Penalty" is an episode of The Anfield Index Podcast. Runtime 20 min. Published November 2, 2026. Hit play above to stream it here, or open the free Spot Sports app for background play and offline downloads.
Episode context
Listen here or keep browsing the show and related sport coverage from here.
Media Matters with Dave Davis and David Lynch | Part 2
Dave Davis is joined by Liverpool journalist David Lynch for another edition of Media Matters, with the controversial refereeing decisions from Liverpool's 1-0 defeat to Arsenal taking centre stage.
Lynch delivers his verdict on Alexander Isak's disputed penalty appeal, questioning why referee Andy Madley and VAR official Michael Oliver failed to intervene following an apparent shirt pull inside the Arsenal penalty area.
However, Lynch also believes Liverpool must take responsibility for failing to make more of the incident. Why didn't Isak appeal more strongly, and are Liverpool's players too honest when competing against the Premier League's most streetwise teams?
The discussion turns to Arsenal's game management, the repeated stoppages that disrupted Liverpool's momentum and a remarkable foul count that saw Liverpool penalised 13 times compared with Arsenal's four.
Lynch explains why he believes the referee allowed Arsenal to dictate the tempo of the match, while Dave raises the reactions of Ian Wright, Peter Schmeichel and Freddie Ljungberg, who also questioned the penalty decision.
With Andoni Iraola suggesting his players may need to go to ground to receive decisions, Dave and Lynch debate whether Premier League refereeing is encouraging players to exaggerate contact.
Was Liverpool denied a clear penalty? Did Arsenal exploit the officials? And should Liverpool have been smarter in their approach?
All this and more on Media Matters with Dave Davis and David Lynch.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Next listen
All from The Anfield Index Podcast →
Next listen
Daily Red: Andoni Iraola Provides Liverpool Injury Update Ahead Of Man United Clash