A chaotic NYCFC draw leads into a must-win homestand

Another New York City FC match packed with storylines and twists, though also another New York City FC match without a win.

This episode starts with hosts Mark Radigan, John Baney, and producer Andrew Leigh going back through the biggest moments of the 2-2 draw in Orlando, like the extremely late, potentially season-saving equalizer from Jonny Shore. So much went on for NYCFC before that goal at 90'+9' but nothing stirred up the reactions quite like Talles Magno attempting and missing a penalty kick late in the second half while New York City trailed by a goal.

Lots of issues with the PK sequence and how it all played out, from the passing over of other possible penalty takers like Nico Fernández Mercau or Alonso Martínez, to the questionable levels of leadership and on-field decision-making shown as it all unfolded. The Shore goal kept it from feeling season-ending, but it definitely felt season-altering.

After the long look back at the Orlando tie, it's on to a discussion about NYCFC's young players in light of the latest MLS 22 Under 22 ranking, which included no New York City players for the second time ever and the first time since 2018. Everyone agrees there are talented young players in the squad, like Shore, Luighi, and a few others, but there are different case-by-case reasons as to why none of them earned a spot on this particular list.

From there, it's on to the extremely dire playoff qualification odds New York City FC now faces after their 2-2 with Orlando City and the results earned by teams above them in the table, plus a preview of this week's two matches at Citi Field against Atlanta United FC and CF Montréal. They have to be back-to-back wins if there's any dream of keeping Decision Day's trip to play DC United meaningful, but how much confidence is there that NYCFC can actually do what's needed even while facing the two bottom teams in the Eastern Conference?

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.