Blue Monday - 8 Points, 4 Points, 0 Points: Does the Club Badge Determine the Punishment?

Everton lost 8 points. Nottingham Forest lost 4. Chelsea? Not a single point, despite admitting to 74 breaches of FA rules and getting hit by three separate regulators (UEFA, the Premier League, and the FA) over £47m in undisclosed historical payments.

Les and Dave lay out the full timeline of all three cases - Everton's two separate PSR breaches, Forest's £34.5m overspend, and Chelsea's Abramovich-era disclosure scandal - and compare them point by point: what the breach actually was, who discovered it, who was punished for it, and what sanction followed.

Are these cases really comparable? Have Chelsea been treated more leniently than the clubs who lost points? We go through the arguments on both sides before giving our verdict.

Let us know your thoughts.

A breakdown of each club’s breaches:

Everton
• Case 1: 2021/22 period. Loss £124.5m vs £105m limit (breach ~£19.5m). Charged Mar 2023.
• Sanction 1: 10-point deduction (Nov 2023) → reduced to 6 points on appeal (Feb 2024).
• Case 2: 2022/23 period. Breach of £16.6m. Charged Jan 2024.
• Sanction 2: 2-point deduction (Apr 2024).
• Total: 8 points deducted, in-season, same campaign.
Nottingham Forest
• Case: 2022/23 period. Threshold £61m (reduced for Championship seasons). Breach of £34.5m. Charged Jan 2024.
• Sanction: 6 points initial → reduced to 4-point deduction for early admission/cooperation.
• Appeal: Rejected — 4 points stood.
Chelsea
• UEFA (2023): €10m (£8.6m) fine — incomplete financial reporting.
• Premier League (Mar 2026): £10.75m fine + immediate 9-month academy transfer ban + 1-year first-team transfer ban suspended 2 years. PL found payments, even if disclosed, would not have breached PSR.
• FA (Jul 2026): 74 admitted breaches (undisclosed agent/third-party payments, £47m, 2011–2018). £10m fine (halved from £20m for self-reporting). Original 6-point suspended deduction overturned on appeal, replaced with suspended two-window transfer ban.
• Total: £0 points deducted. All penalties financial or suspended. Breaches self-reported by current owners about previous (Abramovich) regime.

Want a little more from us? Try The Blue Room Extra for more than 20 hours extra content a month: www.patreon.com/theblueroomextra
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices