Matt Nagy to the Giants: Smart Hire or Just Settling

The New York Giants officially land on Matt Nagy as their next offensive coordinator, and the reaction is exactly what you would expect. After Todd Monken heads to Cleveland, John Harbaugh pivots to Plan B, bypassing names like Kliff Kingsbury and Charlie Weis Jr. and choosing experience over mystery. The crew breaks down why Giants fans are already uneasy, where the criticism of Nagy actually comes from, and why the surface-level stats do not tell the full story of his time in Kansas City or Chicago. Is this really a boring hire, or just a familiar one for a fanbase conditioned to expect disappointment? The conversation then swings to Florham Park, where the New York Jets continue their own coordinator search. Frank Reich, Greg Roman, and Darrell Bevell are on the board, and the guys rank the candidates while unpacking what Aaron Glenn actually needs right now. Giants optimism, Jets uncertainty, and a reminder that sometimes the loudest reactions come from the least informed places.