Giants Fans Can’t Dismiss a Jameis Winston Run

The Giants may have lost Jaxson Dart, but Evan Roberts refuses to accept that their season is finished. He doubles down on his comparison to the 2015 Jets, arguing that Jameis Winston could become the veteran quarterback who unexpectedly keeps the Giants competitive. Shaun Morash admits a nine or 10-win season would be hard for Giants fans to reject, even if Winston ultimately isn’t the long-term answer.

That leads to a bigger debate over what Giants fans should actually want now. Would they rather win big with Winston or lose while young players like Abdul Carter emerge as stars? Evan and Tiki Barber push back hard on the idea that development should matter more than serious winning, while Shaun argues there is more nuance when the difference is only a few wins.