
Listen now
Listen in the appEvan Roberts and Tiki Barber zero in on the stakes for St. John’s and Rick Pitino, debating just how devastating a first-round exit would be and where it would rank among New York sports disappointments. The pressure, expectations, and comparisons to past failures fuel a spirited argument about what truly defines a letdown in this city.
Things then take a turn into classic show chaos with the Cinco de Luncho, where San Diego-themed New York sports moments spark humor, storytelling, and plenty of pushback. From memorable playoff wins to quirky historical moments, the segment delivers laughs while highlighting the unique blend of nostalgia and unpredictability that closes out the show.
Next listen
All from Evan & Tiki →
Next listen
Hour 4: Carmelo Anthony Talks Knicks & The Guys Give Their Predictions for the Knicks
Listen guide
"Cinco Chaos, St. John’s Pressure, and NY Sports Debates" is an episode of Evan & Tiki. Runtime 16 min. Published March 20, 2026. Hit play above to stream it here, or open the free Spot Sports app for background play and offline downloads.