My All Blacks Regret, Rassie Erasmus & the Truth About Coaching

The best coaching stories aren’t about the whiteboard, they’re about what happens years later when an old player stops traffic just to give you a hug. That’s where this conversation with John Plumtree goes fast: past trophies and into the parts of rugby coaching and leadership that actually last. Plum has coached at the highest levels with the Sharks, the Hurricanes, Ireland, and the All Blacks, and he brings a grounded view of culture that cuts through the usual slogans.

We talk about the hidden cost of high performance sport, especially the way coaching can swallow your time and identity if you let it. Plum shares how he thinks about being the best version of himself for his wife, his kids, and his team, plus what changes when you start stepping back from full-time head coaching. From there we get into the real mechanics of pressure: aligning with owners, boards, and stakeholders, and why head coaches are constantly managing three very different relationship groups at once.

Then we go deep on building a winning team culture. Plum’s definition is refreshingly direct: culture is the quality of the people in the building. We unpack what that means for hiring, coaching staff cohesion, and the “triangle” between CEO, head coach, and high performance leadership. He also reflects on international coaching, where selection can matter as much as training, and he shares a rare hindsight lesson from his time with the All Blacks that every ambitious coach will recognize.

If you care about rugby leadership, coaching culture, and building teams that stay connected under stress, you’ll get plenty from this one. Subscribe, share it with a coach who needs it, and leave a review with your biggest takeaway.

Send us Fan Mail

Silverfern Sports
If you need great rugby gear, Silverfern are the best. Innovative high quality rugby kit.

info@coachingculture.com.au

Support the show

Subscribe and Share, it makes a massive difference! Appreciation in advance.