Hour 2: Cam Schlittler Has Taken the Yankees’ Game 1 Spotlight From Gerrit Cole

Cam Schlittler may already be the Yankees’ ace, but should he take the ball over Gerrit Cole in Game 1 of a playoff series? Evan Roberts argues Schlittler has earned the biggest assignment right now, while Shaun Morash leans on Cole’s experience and proposes saving the young star for potential elimination games. Tiki Barber explains why Cole can mentor Schlittler while still desperately wanting to remain the man.

The debate expands into Aaron Boone’s looming decision, Max Fried’s place in the rotation and the backlash the Yankees could face if they choose wrong. Evan, Tiki and Shaun also test their NFL offseason knowledge in “New Team, Who Dis,” examine Breece Hall’s contract compared with the exploding running back market.