Giants Quarterback Search Could Take a Wild Turn

The Giants need another quarterback after losing Jaxson Dart, but how aggressive should they get? A caller proposes trading for J.J. McCarthy, launching a debate over whether New York should sacrifice draft capital for a young quarterback with upside or simply add an available veteran behind Jameis Winston.

Jimmy Garoppolo emerges as a logical possibility, while names like Anthony Richardson, Joe Milton and Pittsburgh’s young quarterbacks enter the conversation as potential lottery tickets. Aaron Rodgers even gets floated if Pittsburgh’s season falls apart, but that idea is quickly rejected as the Giants weigh the difference between finding immediate insurance and taking a chance on someone who could have a future in New York.