Which fandom is cheaper: New York Yankees or St. Louis Cardinals?

New York Yankees and St. Louis Cardinals are effectively tied on monthly cost in their home markets.

Why does the New York Yankees vs St. Louis Cardinals gap exist?

St. Louis Cardinals typically needs 4 services versus 4 for New York Yankees, and local-market rights are usually the main driver of the gap.

Watch Guides Calculator

Fandom Cost Comparison

New York Yankees vs St. Louis Cardinals

Which fandom costs more to stream?

MLB

New York Yankees

$95

/mo

4 services · $758/yr

Cheaper

MLB

St. Louis Cardinals

$95

/mo

4 services · $758/yr

It's basically a tie! Both cost about the same.

Why the gap exists

Setup complexity

St. Louis Cardinals usually asks for 4 services versus 4 for New York Yankees. That is often the first sign the pricier fandom has more rights fragmentation.

League context

New York Yankees ranks #12 in MLB and sits $5 above the league average. St. Louis Cardinals ranks #13 in MLB and sits $5 above the league average.

Price each team for your location

My New York Yankees cost

Customize →

My St. Louis Cardinals cost

Customize →

Keep comparing

Home-market guides

New York Yankees St. Louis Cardinals

Home-city context

New York

How we built this page

Last reviewed April 4, 2026

Both baselines use each team's home market: NEW YORK for New York Yankees and ST. LOUIS for St. Louis Cardinals.
The gap reflects both monthly price and service count, so similar headline prices can still hide setup complexity.
Use the calculator if you follow both teams or live outside either home market.