Mark O'Neill - How Ownership Regulations Shape Football's Future

Football governance sounds dry until you realize it decides whether your club survives. In this episode, Kareem Rae sits down with Mark O'Neill, a PhD researcher at the University of Westminster studying whether football's ownership regulations actually protect the people who matter most: the fans.

Mark breaks down the cases that exposed the cracks in the system, including Dai Yongge's collapse at Reading FC, the Sheffield Wednesday saga, and why the owners and directors test can only act after the damage is done. He explains what England's new independent regulator changes, why English clubs remain a uniquely attractive asset class for American investors, and what the Wrexham story really tells us about buying low in a promotion and relegation system.

The conversation also goes inside the Crystal Palace and Eagle Football case, with Mark, a lifelong Palace supporter, explaining UEFA's controlling influence test in plain terms and why Palace's demotion to the Conference League angered so many fans. Plus: nation-state ownership and the Abramovich precedent, why Mark would ban multi-club ownership outright, FIFA's tax exemptions and ticketing controversies heading into the 2026 World Cup, and the one piece of advice he'd give any first-time club investor.

Topics covered:
- Why the owners and directors test only works after a triggering event
- Reading FC, Sheffield Wednesday, and the checked-out owner problem
- England's new independent football regulator
- English clubs vs American franchises as investment assets
- UEFA's controlling influence test and the Crystal Palace case
- Nation-state ownership and the Chelsea sale
- The case for banning multi-club ownership
- World Cup 2026 governance, taxes, and ticketing

Mark O'Neill Links:
Website: sportlawmusings.com
Substack: substack.com/@markoneill468207
Twitter: x.com/markoneill122no
LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/markoneill3

-------------------------------------------------

🔔

👉 Interested in appearing on the podcast?

Apply Here: onesoccernation.com/apply

-------------------------------------------------

© 2025 One Soccer Nation, under exclusive license to One Soccer Nation LLC.

-------------------------------------------------

DISCLAIMER: Kareem Rae runs One Soccer Nation (OSN) all views expressed by him and the guests on his podcast are solely their opinions and do not reflect the views of One Soccer Nation. You should not treat any opinion expressed by Kareem or his guests as a specific inducement to make a particular investment or follow a particular strategy, but only as an expression of his personal opinion. This podcast is for informational purposes only.

Investment opportunities are offered through One Soccer Nation LLC.

The information contained herein is provided for informational and discussion purposes only and is not intended to be a recommendation for any investment, service, product, or other advice of any kind, and shall not constitute or imply an offer of any kind. Any investment opportunities and/or products or services shown here will only be completed pursuant to formal offering materials, a letter of intent, and/or any other agreements as determined by One Soccer Nation containing full details regarding risks, minimum investment, fees, and expenses of such transaction. The terms of any product, service, or particular investment opportunity, including size, costs, and other characteristics, are set forth in the applicable constituent documents for such product, service or particular investment opportunity and may differ materially from those presented in this presentation. Such terms are subject to change without notice. Quotes included in these materials related to One Soccer Nation’s services should not be construed in any way as an endorsement of One Soccer Nation's advice, analysis, or other service rendered to its clients/investors.

-------------------------------------------------

Chapters:
0:00 Intro: Why football governance decides if your club survives
5:25 Reading FC, Dai Yongge, and the broken owners and directors test
10:57 Why investors buy English clubs: Wrexham and the asset play
15:33 Europe vs the US: where club investment is heading
17:40 Tom Brady & Birmingham City
19:04 Celebrity ownership: Wrexham, Snoop Dogg, and the KSI effect
23:35 How fast a well-run club can collapse under bad ownership
26:53 Can a club fold? Administration, Bury, and the white knight fallacy
32:26 World Cup 2026: ticket prices, politics, and fan exploitation
36:02 Russia, Qatar, and the sportswashing era
40:38 FIFA's tax exemptions and its extractive business model
46:09 Crystal Palace, Eagle Football, and UEFA's controlling influence test
53:26 Is UEFA's March deadline fair? Fixing multi-club rules
1:02:09 Newcastle, the Saudi takeover, and football as diplomacy
1:16:29 Has the Premier League lost its competitive edge?
1:19:04 The enshittification of football