Andrew Painter & The Phillies Take Their Lumps

🔴 PHILLIES IN CRISIS? Andrew Painter STRUGGLES in MLB Debut Era, Alec Bohm BENCHED & Brandon Marsh Is On Fire🔥! Andrew Painter has finally arrived in the big leagues, but it hasn't been smooth sailing. After a brutal 2025 season in Triple-A where he posted a 5.40 ERA in 22 starts with the Lehigh Valley IronPigs, the top pitching prospect is carrying that inconsistency into his MLB debut. Just this week, Painter was lit up by the Athletics — surrendering 7 runs in just 3⅔ innings — as his fastball command issues continue to plague him. Is this just rookie growing pains, or is there a bigger issue with the former No. 1 pitching prospect? We dive deep into whether the Phillies need to manage his workload, send him back down, or trust the process. Meanwhile, Alec Bohm's 2026 nightmare continues. The former All-Star and Phillies cleanup hitter is slashing a dismal .159/.227/.433 OPS through 35+ games — the second-worst OPS of any qualified hitter in all of baseball. This week, interim manager Don Mattingly pinch-hit for Bohm for the FIRST TIME in his career and then sat him entirely the following night in favor of Edmundo Sosa. Is it time to officially bench Bohm? Could a trade be coming? With free agency looming and a personal legal battle off the field, we discuss whether the Phillies can afford to keep running him out there. And in the middle of all this chaos, one Phillie is RAKING: Brandon Marsh. The outfielder has been one of the best hitters in the National League over the last calendar year, slashing .280 in 2025 and now posting a .336/.362/.513 line with 4 home runs and 19 RBIs through his first 33 games in 2026. He ranks second in batting average among all qualified hitters this season. We talk about whether Marsh is finally becoming the player the Phillies always hoped he'd be — and whether he deserves more recognition.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.