Cinco de Luncho: The Next 5 New York Athletes Getting Their Numbers Retired

Cinco de Luncho, sparked by the news that CC Sabathia’s No. 52 is headed for Monument Park. The guys draft the next five New York athletes most likely to have their numbers retired, sparking debates across all four major sports. On the list: Carmelo Anthony’s complicated Knicks legacy, Chris Kreider’s Rangers records and playoff heroics, Jacob deGrom’s emotional Mets case despite finishing elsewhere, and the glaring omission of Darrelle Revis — arguably the greatest Jet ever — whose No. 24 still isn’t retired. Callers weigh in on whether team success should matter, how fan emotion shapes these decisions, and why some franchises move faster than others. The conversation expands into what makes a number-retirement truly meaningful, how rivalries and late-career moves affect legacies, and whether teams sometimes wait for the “right moment” to celebrate former stars. It’s a passionate, cross-town debate to close the hour, mixing nostalgia, hot takes, and a little disbelief at who’s still waiting for the call.